Introduction

Angela Davis is the quintessential scholar-activist. Her career began with graduate studies in French literature and German philosophy, culminating in doctoral research on Kant and violence under the supervision of the critical theorists Theodore Adorno and Herbert Marcuse. Davis’s academic work quickly blended into political action on behalf of Black people, women, and people in prisons. Beginning in 1969, as a new professor at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), Davis’s political activism and membership in the Communist Party attracted the aggressive resistance of the Board of Regents of the University of California, the state government, and ultimately the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). Davis’s experiences are considered a watershed moment in the history of academic freedom and the Black Power movement. This paper draws on archival evidence to weave Davis’s experiences at UCLA together with the stories of two economists: Robert Singleton, a Black scholar in the Graduate School of Business who pursued graduate studies after work in the Civil Rights movement, and James M. Buchanan, a white scholar who was pioneering the study of constitutional order using the tools of economics. Both Singleton and Buchanan intervened in the controversy that engulfed Davis and disrupted her nascent academic career, providing a case study in the application of theories of constitutional and social order at a pivotal point in the history of academic freedom.

Davis’s employment as an assistant professor in the UCLA Philosophy Department was first disrupted by the University of California (UC) Board of Regents in September 1969, when they directed UCLA to fire her for her membership in the Communist Party. This intervention was successfully resisted thanks in part to the support and activism of Robert Singleton, only for the Regents to disrupt Davis’s career a second time when they did not renew her contract in the summer of 1970. Soon after that, in August 1970, Davis’s ties to a shootout at Marin County Courthouse put her on the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s (FBI) Most Wanted List. Singleton again rose to Davis’s defense when she went underground, while James M. Buchanan privately urged the UC Regents to use what he called the “wonderful opportunity” of the four deaths at the shootout to purge Davis’s defenders from the UC system. The differences in the Regents’ response to the two economists were stark. Singleton was flatly denied an audience when he reached out to the Regents in September 1969, but when Buchanan wrote to the Regents about Davis in August 1970, he was deluged with prompt and supportive replies. Clearly, Singleton and Buchanan approached Davis’s employment, arrest, and trial in dramatically different ways, despite sharing a professional background in economics and being faculty colleagues at UCLA during the 1968–1969 academic year.

I argue that Buchanan’s response is particularly intriguing because it cuts against claims by scholars as diverse as Nancy MacLean (2017) and Jean-Baptiste Fleury and Alain Marciano (2018) who are in agreement that Buchanan insisted on a rigid constitutional order in the university. At least in the particular context of the Angela Davis case, it was Robert Singleton who insisted on the maintenance of constitutional norms and order, while Buchanan sought to circumvent them and assert a more punitive and discretionary order with restricted employment and speech rights for Communist Party members. This differs from typical characterization and self-characterizations of Buchanan’s views on social order as a rejection of discretionary power. For example, Brennan and Buchanan (1985, 54) argue that “the model of self-interest, or Homo economicus, will tip the balance of argument in favor of assigning less discretionary power to political agents than would be the case under the benevolence model.”

Buchanan’s experiences at UCLA have been documented by MacLean (2017) and Fleury and Marciano (2018), so I only briefly review them here. However, his involvement with the Angela Davis affair has been entirely neglected. This paper adds to the literature on Buchanan’s views on constitutional order in the university (MacLean 2017; Fleury and Marciano 2018; Hall 2020; Levy and Peart 2020; Boettke, Clark, and Kroencke 2022) by identifying a case of Buchanan as a proponent of achieving social order through discretionary power. It also contrasts Buchanan’s response to the events at UCLA with Singleton’s response, on which there is currently no literature in the history of economics.1

To keep Davis, Singleton, and Buchanan’s interwoven storylines clear, this paper proceeds chronologically, first focusing on the 1968–1969 academic year that encompassed the planning and launch of Singleton’s Afro-American Studies Center (AASC),2 and Buchanan’s year at the UCLA Economics Department. This was a stage setting year for what was to come next for both Singleton and Buchanan in their relationship with Angela Davis. The paper then moves to Davis’s time at UCLA, the 1969-1970 academic year. It concludes with the period after the summer of 1970, including Angela Davis’s arrest and Buchanan’s use of Davis to promote his view of academic order and academic freedom. This means that in some sections of the paper Singleton is naturally more prominent, and in other sections Buchanan is. For better or worse, history does not uniformly distribute the critical contributions of its cast of characters. If Angela Davis herself sometimes seems to be superseded by Robert Singleton in my account, it is only because my purpose is to elaborate Singleton’s largely neglected story. My intent is not to question or reevaluate Davis’s vigorous self-advocacy, which is already documented elsewhere (e.g., Aptheker 2014; Davis 1974; Davis and Wiener 2020).

Introducing Robert Singleton

By his 1968 arrival in Los Angeles, James M. Buchanan was an established scholar, well known for his contributions to public finance and the emerging field of public choice. He would go on to win the Nobel Prize in 1986 and be closely associated with the University of Virginia (UVA), Virginia Tech, and George Mason University. In contrast, Robert Singleton is essentially unknown to historians of economics, so some introduction is required. Singleton received his bachelor’s degree in international relations from UCLA in 1960, after serving in the Army in Europe. He received his MA in international trade and finance from UCLA in 1963 (originally thinking that he would pursue international relations) and then worked towards a PhD in economics, which he earned in 1983 after many years teaching as an “all but dissertation” (ABD) student.3 After earnings his master’s degree but before earning his PhD, Singleton’s role in the Civil Rights Movement would draw his scholarly focus away from international relations and toward domestic topics more directly relevant to Black Americans, particularly in California.

Singleton describes the lasting influence of experiencing racial discrimination starting with his basic training at Fort Benning in 1954, when he went off base into segregated Augusta, Georgia. Singleton shares that although parts of his experience on base were difficult, he did not have to deal with racial discrimination there. The Army had been integrated by Truman in 1948, and for the most part integration took. Off base, though, Singleton and other Black Americans had to abide by Jim Crow (Kwan 2018). When he left the Army to study at UCLA, he served as the student president of the campus NAACP. This activism led to Singleton’s participation in protests at the local Woolworth’s store and in a 1961 Freedom Ride that landed him and his wife in a Mississippi jail.4 After the Freedom Rides, back at UCLA in the late 1960s, Singleton refocused his research on racial inequality in education and employment. He began working on his doctorate at UCLA under the supervision of Jack Hirshliefer, studying whether the minimum wage hurt “disadvantaged workers” (U.S. Department of Labor 1967, 54). Singleton’s base at UCLA in the late 1960s and early 1970s was the Graduate School of Management, where he was an assistant professor. In 1970, he co-founded the Journal of Black Studies with Molefi Kete Asante, the second director of the AASC. Singleton ultimately stopped working with Hirshliefer and finished his doctorate in 1983 with a dissertation on the capitalization of California’s Proposition 13 (Singleton 1983). Later in his career, he would also write on the economics education (Singleton 1991; Anderson et al. 2005).

In 1968 and 1969, Singleton’s views on constitutional order were grounded primarily in his activism in the Civil Rights Movement, which fought for concrete public accommodation rights. This differed from Buchanan, whose views on constitutional order were grounded in the emerging academic field of constitutional economics. Singleton’s response to Angela Davis can be understood as a continuation of his civil rights work in the context of the university. He advocated for Angela Davis on and off campus and was chairman of the Angela Davis Defense Committee. The Los Angeles Herald Examiner deemed Singleton “her principal supporter” (Hanna 1969), although subsequent histories have largely ignored his role, focusing instead on white professors such as Don Kalish and Leon Letwin.

Singleton’s advocacy on behalf of Davis built on his approach to advocating for civil rights: the consistent insistence on the recognition of constitutional rights in cases where they were violated. His commitment to these constitutional principles was sharpened, rather than broken, when confronted with resistance. Singleton shared how he and his wife’s commitment to joining the Freedom Rides became resolute after the Ku Klux Klan firebombed a bus of Freedom Riders in Anniston, Alabama, on May 14, 1961. He shared that “we were talking about joining [the Freedom Rides] and somehow getting involved, but that bus burning was really what triggered our involvement wholesale” (Kwan 2018).

With this overview of Singleton’s academic and civil rights career, we are now prepared to explore the events that rocked UCLA in the 1968–1969 academic year, and how Singleton, Buchanan, and Davis experienced these events.

1968–1969: Planning the AASC and Buchanan’s Year at UCLA

In the late 1960s, Black college students across the United States began demanding instruction that was relevant to the Black community and delivered by dedicated Black Studies departments and centers (Huggins 1985; Rojas 2010 Collisson 2008; Henry 2017; Alkalimat 2021). When Buchanan arrived at UCLA in the fall of 1968, the UCLA Black Students Union (BSU) and its faculty partners were already making progress on their own Afro-American Studies Center (AASC). The BSU had been working with history professor Larry Kincaid for almost a year to develop the center, which was initially called the Center for the Study of Afro-American History and Culture. Together, the BSU and Kincaid cultivated the support of at least twenty-nine faculty and the administration.5 Outside UCLA, the BSU was in contact with Robert S. Browne, then an assistant professor of economics at Fairleigh Dickinson, for advice on the Center’s curriculum.6 Presumably with the UCLA BSU and similar student groups in mind, Browne (1997, 55) remembers the late 1960s as a time when his “racial conscience was being pricked” by the efforts of “black militant students seeking to recruit black professors.”

Robert Singleton was a member of the AASC steering committee by October 1968, although it would be several more months until he would be selected as director.7 Although he was initially interested in international economics, by the mid-1960s Singleton’s research was focused on the economic experiences of Black Americans and other marginalized groups. As a graduate student he published on the problem of high school dropouts (Bullock and Singleton 1962), “direct and indirect” discrimination in Los Angeles schools (Singleton and Bullock 1963), and the employment of Mexican-Americans in Los Angeles.8

In addition to their efforts planning the AASC, the BSU advocated hiring more Black faculty. In the fall of 1968, they confronted the UCLA Economics Department on its failure to hire any Black faculty. The Economics Department was hardly the only culprit on campus, but it was easily the most combative towards the students seeking change. Economics Department Chairman William R. Allen bristled at demands for more equitable hiring and on multiple occasions used racialized social services analogies to dismiss the students. Allen complained that the demand to hire Black faculty would turn the university into a “social welfare agency” (Allen quoted in Sward 1969, 30) and that “you just don’t find excellent Ph.D.’s hanging around the state employment centers” (Allen quoted in Kumbula 1968, 21).9 Allen also had a dehumanizing habit of referring to Black student and faculty leaders on campus as “specimens.” The BSU students who advocated hiring more Black faculty were “fascistic specimens who neither know nor care to learn the necessary conditions of viable civilization” (Allen 1968), and later Angela Davis was “an interesting specimen of the Very Far Left.”10 In a letter that was sent to but not ultimately published in the Daily Bruin, UCLA law professor Leon Letwin decried Allen’s “Olympian detachment” from the problem of discrimination against Black students and scholars and his “disavowal of the Department’s responsibility for helping to change a situation produced by historic injustices” (Espinoza 2017, 145). History professor A.J. Slavin wrote in the Daily Bruin that “Allen’s discussion is itself a kind of rank norm of brutality” (Slavin 1968).

Allen’s accounts of the BSU as a malevolent force may give the false impression that all economists on campus besides Singleton dismissed the students and their efforts. This was not the case. Werner Z. Hirsch, a professor in the Economics Department and director of the Institute of Government and Public Affairs, supported the AASC during its early development and invited BSU member Virgil Roberts to participate in a panel discussion alongside faculty members.11 George Murphy, an associate professor in the department, agreed to lead one of the AASC’s research projects at Singleton’s request in 1969.12 Hirsch and Murphy’s good relations with the BSU and later with the AASC were not representative of the Economics Department, but they demonstrate that Allen’s hostility was not universally shared, even if it carried the day for departmental policy.

Allen’s reaction to the BSU, while distinctive for its aggressivity, was no different in substance from other white economics faculties across the country in 1968. A handful of economics departments dominated by white faculty reacted to demands for integration by making an effort to hire or admit Black economists, most notably at MIT (Darity and Kreeger 2014), Stanford (Simms and Conrad 2019), the University of Michigan-Ann Arbor (Betsey 2019), and Harvard (Myers 2017), although these were the rare exceptional cases.

After his confrontation with the BSU, Allen reported that he received threatening phone calls, and he reacted to those calls and to the BSU by buying a 12-gauge shotgun and lacing his lawn with tripwire. Allen’s wife reported a driver and passenger backing out of their driveway to the police, apparently only because they were “both Black” (there is no indication in Allen’s account that they had done anything besides make a wrong turn). Within days of Allen’s gun purchase, a student discovered an unexploded pipe bomb at the entrance to Bunche Hall, which housed the Economics Department.13 Allen, of course, was convinced the bomb was related to demands to hire Black faculty and Goetz (2013) remembers Buchanan blaming the Black Panther Party specifically. Despite Allen’s frequently repeated theory blaming students, police were adamant that there was “absolutely no evidence” that the BSU was involved (Greenwood 1968).

Far more significant for the UCLA community than the attempted bombing, though, was the murder of BSU students John Huggins and Alprentice “Bunchy” Carter two months later on January 17, 1969, during a meeting to discuss the selection of a director for the AASC. Their shooter was Claude “Chuchessa” Hubert, a member of the United Slaves (US) Organization. US’s leader, Ron Karenga, was particularly interested in using new Black Studies departments and centers like the AASC to promote his cultural vision of Black nationalism as a competitor to the Black Panther Party. Despite this rivalry, the BSU insisted that UCLA students, and not the US Organization (or for that matter the Panthers), should shape the future of the AASC. On January 15, the BSU informed UCLA Chancellor Charles Young that they had resolved that the direction of the Center “must have the approval of the Black Students’ Union.”14

Both Singleton and Buchanan were in the vicinity of the shooting. Singleton was actually in Campbell Hall, and Buchanan was working in the adjacent Bunche Hall. Singleton remembers that police were “stopping blacks at random” outside the building and putting them in handcuffs. He stepped in to mediate amidst the chaos and encourage the police to stop the indiscriminate arrests that were only raising tensions (UCLA Graduate Quarterly 2010, 24). After the murders, the students’ resolve hardened even further to launch their Center and have a serious scholar lead it rather than someone manipulated by Karenga.

Huggins and Carter were Black Panthers, so the Party was naturally outraged at the murders and had no trouble connecting the dots between the US Organization and its handlers in the FBI, LAPD, and state government.15 The Party also made its intentions with respect to the AASC both clear and distinct from Karenga’s, insisting that despite the enrollment of some Panthers at UCLA, “control of UCLA’s Black Student Program is not an objective of the Black Panther Party.” They continued that “the Black Panther Party would not trade a block of Central Avenue for the whole city of Westwood,” a reference to their own headquarters downtown and to UCLA’s affluent Los Angeles neighborhood (Black Panther Party 1969).

Angela Davis was personally closer to the shootings than either Singleton or Buchanan. In early 1969, she was living and working in Los Angeles as a leader in the local Student Nonviolent Coordinating Council (SNCC) chapter, although she had not yet been hired to teach at UCLA. When she heard about the shooting, she rushed to the apartment of Huggins’s widow, Ericka, and their daughter Mai. Davis describes how despite recent disputes with the local Panthers,16 she “had an enormous respect and admiration for [John Huggins] and felt he was in good faith in his determination to find a solution to the crisis within the Party” (Davis 1974, 195).

In contrast with Davis’s “enormous respect and admiration” for the dead, Buchanan saw Huggins and Carter as criminals. The November bombing attempt on the Economics Department had already convinced Buchanan he needed to leave Los Angeles, but the murders provided an opportunity to announce his decision, and he submitted his official resignation within days.17 In his resignation letter Buchanan accused UCLA of having “a deliberate policy to recruit black militants, some of whom have long-standing criminal records, who do not meet standard admission requirements, and who have no conception of a university” (“UCLA Prof Quits Over Violence” 1969, 52). Buchanan wrote his resignation letter in ignorance of the FBI’s covert war against the Black Panther Party under J. Edgar Hoover’s COINTELPRO, including the Bureau’s instigation of the murder of Huggins and Carter. All Buchanan saw in the melee was “a deliberate policy to recruit black militants” and a failed university administration.18

Buchanan’s assertion that students “do not meet standard admissions requirements” was a clear reference to the High Potential Program (HPP), a new initiative to improve access to UCLA for Black and Latino students who did not meet formal eligibility requirements but showed potential for high academic performance. To be accepted into HPP, applicants had to prove “basic intelligence, self-assuredness, and motivation and endurance” in interviews with UCLA students of the same race and ethnicity. The HPP provided students with tutoring and supports for university success. The committee that helped develop the HPP included Virgil Roberts, the BSU student who spearheaded the creation of the AASC (Rhodes 1970, 12).

Progress on the AASC temporarily halted in the wake of the murders, but by April the work was back on track, and Robert Singleton was selected as director of the Center. He had known Chancellor Young for years (UCLA Graduate Quarterly 2010), he satisfied BSU demands that a qualified academic serve as a director, and he was mutually agreeable to the Panthers and the US Organization (Henry 2017).

In March 1969, around the time Singleton became director of the AASC and Buchanan announced he would leave UCLA, Angela Davis was offered a teaching position in the UCLA Philosophy Department. She had an offer from Swarthmore and had interviewed at Princeton, but she selected UCLA so that she could continue her political work in Los Angeles (Davis 1974). Although Davis’s scholarship would ultimately be most closely associated with prison abolition (Davis 1971, 2003) and intersectional feminism (Davis 1981), in 1969 she was known for her doctoral research on Kant’s analysis of violence and her elaboration of Marcuse’s work on the unity of theory and practice (Roberts 2021). The latter in particular was radical. Davis’s hire helped “maintain the department’s reputation for intellectual fearlessness” (Davis and Wiener 2020, 473). In general, the “logicians and positivists” were not as enthusiastic about hiring Davis as the “dialecticians and Hegelians” (Aptheker 2014, 2). An important exception to this alignment was Chairman Don Kalish, a logician who championed Davis’s hiring. Whatever their views initially, every member of the department united behind her when her position was challenged by the Regents.

In May, after Buchanan submitted his resignation and Davis received her job offer, protest activity accelerated at UCLA against the use of deadly force by police at UC Berkeley and the war in Vietnam. In response, Economics Chairman Allen posted a memo titled “Marauders and survival” advising faculty on how to behave if their classes were disrupted by protesters. Allen recommended preparing a plan in advance and dismissing the class if the situation got out of hand. He requested faculty report the details of any disruption to him.19 Allen was not finished. The following day, Allen posted a second memo titled “Enforcement of faculty contracts,” which more pointedly announced that he would consider any faculty member who joined the protesters and used classroom time to discuss “the present crisis” in breach of contract.20 A third posted memo titled “Prosecution of class interruptions” disclosed that Allen had spoken with a District Attorney and stood ready to bring charges against classroom protesters for disturbing the peace.21 An anonymous letter writer who had knowledge of the memos described them as “intimidating edicts” and insisted that “the choice of whether or not to discuss relevant issues should be a matter of the instructor’s personal conscience” (UCLA Daily Bruin 1969, 8). Allen suspected that the letter writer was Firouz Vakil, an Iranian doctoral candidate that was teaching at UCLA that year. Allen wrote to Glenn Campbell, one of the UC Regents, to complain that Vakil was “a devious individual” who he believed should be fired.22

Allen’s battles with the BSU and student protesters boiled over into friction with Robert Singleton himself. Allen lodged a complaint with the UCLA administration about Singleton in May 1969, a month after he started as director of the AASC. The substance of the complaint is not extant in the Singleton Papers or the Buchanan Papers, but apparently the administration ignored Allen since he submitted a second complaint the following year, mentioning the lack of a response to his first.23 Just as Allen was one of the few UCLA faculty to actively fight BSU demands to hire more Black faculty, he appears to have been the only faculty member to formally complain (twice) about Singleton’s work at the AASC.

Amidst the Spring protests, Buchanan drafted a book titled Academia in Anarchy, which was coauthored with Nicos Devletoglou, a Greek economist trained at the London School of Economics who was visiting the UCLA Economics Department. Most of Devletoglou’s research was concerned with industrial organization, although he shared Buchanan’s apprehensions about the protest movements of the 1960s. He had recently published a study of what he characterized as “disquieting instances of misuse of the power to demonstrate freely” against the Greek royal family (Devletoglou 1966). Buchanan and Devletoglou brought the same skepticism of free speech and student protests to the task of writing their book. Academia in Anarchy is often discounted as a reactionary lashing out at the student movement, and perhaps it is.24 But the book itself purports to be a serious application of economic theory to university life, encompassing university finances, faculty behavior, and trends in student sexuality and violence.

Academia in Anarchy has two parts. The first lays out the authors’ views on the economics of the university and the student movement. Buchanan and Devletoglou (1970) argue that the movement was attributable to students’ status as “consumers who do not buy” their education. Tuition was heavily subsidized and students bore minimal direct financial costs, so they did not truly value college. Buchanan and Devletoglou (1970) also argue that faculty were often complicit in radical student movements because they were “producers who do not sell.” Faculty appeased radical students because they had no stake in the institution, which led to even more extreme demands by the students. The second part of the book lays out Buchanan and Devletoglou’s (1970) “economics of violence,” and the necessity of harsh repercussions and budgetary restrictions on higher education to control university chaos. Academia in Anarchy does not mention Angela Davis by name, which is not surprising because although it was published in early 1970, after her initial confrontation with the Regents, it was drafted quickly in the Spring of 1969, even before she made headlines as a member of the Communist Party.

The FBI took the arguments of Academia in Anarchy seriously enough to write a five-page memorandum on the book and keep a copy in their Domestic Intelligence Division – the division responsible for COINTELPRO and the instigation of the murders of Huggins and Carter. For the most part, the FBI memorandum provides an objective synopsis of Buchanan and Devletoglou’s argument, although in an unguarded moment of editorialization, the FBI reviewer refers to the book as “devastatingly persuasive.”25

1969–1970: Angela Davis’s Year at UCLA and the Launch of the AASC

In early July 1969, Angela Davis’s employment at UCLA quickly transformed from a promising and uncontroversial young faculty hire into a university crisis. On July 1st William Divale, an undercover FBI agent, asserted in the Daily Bruin that a Communist had been hired as a faculty member. On July 9th, Davis was revealed to be that faculty member in the San Francisco Examiner. Over the rest of the summer the Regents and Davis engaged in increasingly tense administrative exchanges until it was finally clear that the Regents would move to terminate her employment because she was a Communist. To meet the crisis, the Ad Hoc Group for the Defense of Academic Freedom, which included both Angela Davis and Robert Singleton, formed and met on September 15th. At the meeting, Singleton spoke about how in addition to an administrative and legal strategy, the group needed to support Davis personally and financially. This had to include coverage of her summer stipend and any lost salary during the year.26 Davis could not just be a symbol of academic freedom and racial justice; she needed to eat and pay rent. That required material support.

The Ad Hoc Group quickly became less ad hoc and organized into the Angela Davis Defense Campaign. Singleton was the Chair of the Angela Davis Defense Committee, the most important of the six committees making up the Defense Campaign. His committee was responsible for “overall planning of the campaign,” the “determination of official campaign policy,” and acting as the campaign’s “liaison with Professor Davis’s Attorneys.”27 Singleton was therefore at the nerve center of Angela Davis’s organized defense on campus. He also publicly identified her cause with the AASC’s cause, saying that she was “important to the center’s program” (Gilmore 1969).

Singleton planned to speak to the Regents during a closed session of their September 19th meeting, but he was denied permission to speak. Rebuffed by the Regents, he made his case to reporters congregated outside (Reich and Trombley 1969; Davies 1969). He warned that “any discipline meted to her is bound to be regarded as a not too subtle move to warn Blacks about the consequences of militancy and protest.” Singleton continued that, “the Regents may be vitally concerned, perhaps obsessed, with Miss Davis’s political views. The Black community is, however, far more concerned with her dedication to making her community’s future more bright than its dark and terrible past.”28

Singleton was always clear that he came from what he characterized as the non-violent direct-action tradition of the Civil Rights Movement rather than the newer Black Power movement, but this alternative orientation was never a distraction from the necessity of aligning with Davis, because in his words “we believe a purge of bigots is more important than one of communists.” The Regents’ reaction would predictably affect efforts to hire Black professors, so that “the already desperately difficult task of recruiting Black faculty will border on the impossible if Professor Davis is punished for her militancy.”29 Black academics would think twice about applying for jobs in the UC system if the Regents set themselves against qualified scholars who engaged in activism. The Regents emerged from the closed-door meeting with a resolution directing President Hitch to terminate Davis’s employment.

Progressive faculty in the Law School and the Committee of Concerned Faculty (CCF) privately met to determine the faculty response to the situation in the following days. The faculty in these meetings unanimously sided with Davis against the Regents, but they were irreparably divided over whether to frame the “predominate issue” of the case as one of racism or academic freedom. Philosophy professor Wade Savage30 worried “that the racial issue would destroy the CCF by causing splits.” Singleton was not high in the academic hierarchy, but he spoke against Savage and in favor of centering the charge of racism in the faculty’s response. Despite Singleton’s efforts, “the majority” felt that “white support can’t be gathered under” the perspective that racism was the “predominate issue” in the Angela Davis case. The CCF made no resolution at the meeting.31

The same day as the CCF meeting, Singleton appeared at Davis’s side at a press conference. Davis began the press conference by announcing that she would seek a hearing before the faculty committee responsible for handling her dismissal. She asserted that the Regents were targeting her for her role in “the struggle for black liberation.” After Davis addressed the press, Singleton approached the mic and asserted that “racism is the overriding issue in this case” (Singleton quoted in Reich 1969, 3). The response was electric and newspapers across the country reported on the gauntlet that Davis and Singleton—two UCLA professors who were both still graduate students themselves—threw down.

The day after the news conference, Singleton’s AASC distributed a “Letter to the Black Community,” encouraging Black Angelenos to support Angela Davis against the Regents. The letter began with a review of her qualifications to teach and then reiterated Singleton’s point that “the Regents have fired Angela Davis, not because she is a Communist, but because she is a black woman, militant and aggressive in her approach to the problems of black people.” The AASC letter also promoted a fundraising effort to replace Davis’s salary and pay her legal fees.32 Buchanan, meanwhile, published an extended criticism of UCLA in the Washington Post on October 18, 1969, lamenting that “any hope for responsible faculty and administration behavior seems lost after the current Davis affair.”33

Amidst the speeches, articles, letters, and organizing, Davis wanted an opportunity to prove her qualifications and dedication to teaching, so she requested to teach Recurring Philosophical Themes in Black Literature for the Fall semester. Whether she was aware of it or not, Davis picked a course that Singleton and Don Kalish had been trying to cover with a temporary hire for months. Failing to find anyone, Kalish wrote to Singleton in June that “unless one of us can, like the magician, pull an instructor out of a hat,” they would need to “encourage those who wanted to enroll to schedule the course into their Spring quarter plans – at which time Angela Davis will give it.”34 They were trying to preserve Davis’s Fall semester so that she could make progress on her dissertation, but they nevertheless granted her request to teach the course. Davis’s lectures exceeded expectations and definitively proved her brilliance and talent for teaching. Art Seidenbaum (1969) joked that if “University Extension were to take over the Davis course right now and sell tickets, the revenue might support a new building without a bond issue.”

In October, Judge Pacht of the Los Angeles Superior Court found that the Regents had no grounds to fire Davis simply because she was a member of the Communist Party.35 Despite her court victory, Davis faced continuing criticism inside and outside academia, so part of Singleton’s work on the Angela Davis Defense Committee included responding to critics in the broader Los Angeles community. When the local CBS station defended the Regents’ attempted firing of Davis, Singleton wrote an editorial describing how the news segment was “either mistaken or sloppily researched,” and outlined their confused account of the case law around political tests for professors. Singleton suspected “the ulterior motive of the Regents is something they fear more than membership in the Communist Party,” which was “her membership in numerous Black Militant Organizations.” He reiterated that “if this is the motivation of the Regents it is a form of racism.”36

As chair of the Defense Committee, Singleton was also increasingly seen as a gatekeeper for people seeking insight into or contact with Davis. Robert Jackson, an inmate at Deer Island Prison in Massachusetts, reached out to Singleton asking to be put in touch with Davis in April 1970. Jackson knew that Davis had emerged as an advocate for the men incarcerated at Soledad Prison in California and hoped that she could help the situation at Deer Island, which he described as “dreadful.” Jackson wrote to Singleton three months before participating in a hunger strike to protest conditions at Deer Island.37 The next year, the journalist Regina Nadelson reached out to and interviewed Singleton for her 1972 book, Who is Angela Davis?: The Biography of a Revolutionary.38

While Robert Singleton was organizing for Davis in Los Angeles, James M. Buchanan was growing increasingly angry with the student movement and UCLA faculty’s defiance of the Regents. Buchanan left UCLA for Virginia Tech before Davis started teaching, but he “retained an active interest in the behavior of all parties to the Angela Davis affair since her initial appointment.”39 Virginia was not immune to the student movement, and Buchanan worried that anti-war protests at UVA and increasingly at Virginia Tech would spill over into other parts of the state.40 He wrote to Benjamin Woodbridge, a member of the Virginia House of Delegates, about the importance of putting university administrators “on notice that Virginia taxpayers will simply not continue to finance seedbeds of revolution.”41 Writing to his former UVA colleague Leland Yeager, Buchanan confided that “those few of us who do not like what is happening” may be “forced out of academia altogether as the mob begins to feel its muscle.” He admitted to Yeager that his preferred solution to campus radicals was “selective financial sanctions” imposed by the state, although he doubted this was possible.42

Angela Davis and her supporters recognized the dangers posed by this vision of public finance as a tool to repress professors and students. For example, Herbert Marcuse noted in a speech at Berkeley’s Sproul Plaza that the Regents learned from their failed attempt to fire Davis that “[t]here are other and more effective ways of repressing the university, namely, via the budget (a very favorite means) and via a pre-censorship and control of appointments, promotions, and so on before they are made so that they don’t have to go to the courts afterwards.”43 Revisiting the same theme in 1974, Marcuse called the job insecurity facing “radical young professor[s]” like Angela Davis “economic repression,” which was imposed in conjunction with physical repression by the state.44

Outside Virginia, Buchanan also kept in touch with Senator Gordon Allott (R – CO) about maintaining order in higher education. Allott was an outspoken critic of Nixon’s Commission on Campus Unrest, which he considered too soft on student protesters.45 He told Buchanan, “we share many opinions about the problems currently affecting our universities,” mentioning in particular their mutual disapproval of Alexander Heard.46 Heard was a special advisor to Nixon on campus unrest, but his approach was diametrically opposed to Buchanan’s. Heard embraced the student movement as Chancellor of Vanderbilt University because he believed that students had valuable contributions to make to university governance, and that respecting those contributions was essential for diffusing tensions. Although he was no radical, Heard was not reactionary or dismissive in his engagements with the Black Power movement. He famously supported Stokely Carmichael’s appearance for a speech at Vanderbilt, despite vigorous opposition from the university’s board (Conkin 1985). From Buchanan’s perspective, Heard shared all the failings of the UCLA administration.

There are two ways to understand how Buchanan approached Angela Davis, both with some merit but one more persuasive than the other. The first is to see his argument against her as a contradiction between the theory and practice of constitutional order in the university. Under this interpretation, Buchanan theorized an order structured by stable (albeit consensually amendable) rules of the game, but he abandoned that theory and any pretense of consensual amendment in practical cases, such as faculty’s constitutional authority over hiring, and students’ Constitutional right to protest.47 A second interpretation is that Buchanan promoted alternative theories of order at different points in his career, and that in UCLA he adopted a broader role for political discretion. This second interpretation is appealing because, after all, Buchanan was not in any practical way responsible for decision making around Davis’s employment. It therefore is not really a case of contradictions between theory and practice. In Academia in Anarchy, Buchanan and Devletoglou (1970, 160) consider the prospects of “long-range changes in the constitutional structure of the university” more amenable to their constitutional preferences. However, they doubt that these changes can come about through faculty action and concede that a range of responses can be expected from boards of governors. Legislatures offered some of the best opportunities for change, but “they have been prevented from effectively containing terror on their campuses by court rulings based on the familiar principle of due process and free speech” (Buchanan and Devletoglou 1970, 166). Ideally, Buchanan and Devletoglou (1970) argued, legislatures would respond unencumbered to university “chaos” by withholding funding.

The Marin County Courthouse as Buchanan’s “Wonderful Opportunity”

Almost a year to the day after the murders of Huggins and Carter, three men incarcerated in Soledad Prison were charged with murdering a prison guard. The “Soledad Brothers” – George Jackson, Fleeta Drumgo, and John Cluchette – maintained their innocence and believed that they were being framed because of Jackson’s radical politics. Angela Davis took up the cause of the Soledad Brothers in the Spring 1970 semester and soon became the public face of the campaign to free them. In retaliation for her Soledad Brothers activism, Davis’s contract was not renewed by the UC Board of Regents after the 1969–1970 academic year. The decision was transparently ideological, but it was on firmer legal footing than their initial attempted firing in September 1969 because the Regents had no legal obligation to renew her contract.

A few members of the Economics Department joined with other UCLA faculty in protesting Davis’s non-renewal, including Charles Nisbet, Firouz Vakil (the previous target of Allen), and Bryan Ellickson, but apparently none of their colleagues stood with them.48 Vakil pleaded in a letter to the department that “eventually we may not be able to remain with our heads beneath the sand.” These dissenting economists were considerably more at ease with student culture than the departmental leadership. For example, Nisbet and Vakil (1972) surveyed almost a thousand UCLA students on their marijuana use to estimate demand elasticities for marijuana.

Angela Davis (right) demonstrating on behalf of the Soledad Brothers with Jonathan Jackson (left), June 19th, 1970. Made available for reproduction under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License by UCLA Charles E. Young Research Library Department of Special Collections.

Allen was livid at the idea that his economics faculty would support Angela Davis and mockingly asked Vakil if “faulty toilet training” as a child was the ultimate cause of his views.49 Allen accused Nisbet of “superciliousness, sarcasm, innuendo, false piety, machination, and misrepresentation.”50 All of Allen’s correspondence with the departmental dissenters was forwarded on to Buchanan, who was following the Davis situation from Virginia.51

Davis’s activism on behalf of the Soledad Brothers was destined to have ramifications for her life well beyond being fired from UCLA. In August, George Jackson’s 17-year-old brother Jonathan used guns owned by Davis to take Judge Harold Haley, a prosecutor, and three jurors hostage in the Marin County Courthouse during the trial of a man named James McClain. Jackson had access to Davis’s guns because he served as one of her bodyguards after she was deluged with death threats. As Jackson moved the hostages away from the courthouse, police fired on them and killed four. Because Davis’s guns were used in the attack, she was put on the FBI’s Most Wanted List for murder and kidnapping. She immediately went underground.

While Davis was on the run from the FBI, Robert Singleton again rose to her defense. In a letter coauthored with Marie Branch52 to Nommo Magazine he called J. Edgar Hoover “the Assassin” and warned that “the only reason he has put her on the ‘ten most wanted list’ and declared her ‘armed and dangerous’ is to give his killers license to murder her on sight.” Singleton and Branch also linked the FBI’s targeting of Davis to the murders of Huggins and Carter in 1969. Both events marked “an irreversible change among most of the Black people here” at UCLA.53

James M. Buchanan also reacted immediately to the courthouse incident by writing to California Governor Ronald Reagan and the UC Board of Regents demanding that they take action against Davis’s supporters. Davis had already been removed from the faculty, but Buchanan’s target now was the university administration that he blamed for Davis’s hire and for what he saw as the broader chaos across American higher education. Buchanan expressed no doubts about Davis’s guilt in his letter to the UC Regents, and he showed no interest in defending Davis as a fellow member of the academy. Instead, he accused “the departmental faculty in philosophy, and notably Chancellor Young and his administration” of “trying to twist ‘academic freedom’ to defend the appointment, retention, and reappointment of a revolutionary who has now carried out what she promised to do all along.” Chancellor Young and the faculty who defended Davis “have seriously undermined the whole concept of academic freedom.”54 Buchanan wrote even less guardedly in a separate letter sent to Reagan, encouraging the governor to seize “this opportunity to rid the university of its soft-headed administration without the dangers of a liberal backlash.”55

The responses to Buchanan demonstrate that despite their reputation as ruling the UC system with an iron fist, the Regents did not see themselves as masterminds orchestrating events. They reacted, sometimes clumsily and overzealously, to what transpired around them and often felt personally disempowered. In their replies to Buchanan, many Regents used the word “frustration” to describe their experience with the Davis case and conceded that they felt embattled and not in control of the situation. Angela Davis did not have tenure, but Regent John E. Canaday nevertheless wrote to Buchanan about the difficulty they face in firing tenured faculty members and his own desire to revise those restrictions on the Regents’ power.56

UC President Charles Hitch also received a personalized letter from Buchanan encouraging him to “use this opportunity to get rid of [Chancellor] Young,” who was “an extremely dangerous man, as I saw from personal contacts last year.” Young, the new liberal UCLA chancellor, had backed Angela Davis and supported the formation of the AASC and the HPP. Buchanan predicted that if Young remained at the university, “UCLA can only be destroyed,” and advised Hitch (who voted to keep Angela Davis) that “the Davis case can be used as the means of correcting a notoriously bad error of judgement in appointing Young in the first place.”57

Buchanan’s letter counseling President Hitch to “get rid of” Young concealed the fact that President Hitch himself was also one of Buchanan’s targets. Writing separately to the Regent Glenn Campbell (Director of the Hoover Institution, and fellow economist), Buchanan characterized “the whole Davis deal” as “a wonderful opportunity to rid the system of Young, Hitch, and others who have been in any way responsible for the Davis appointment and proposed reappointment.”58 So, while Buchanan worked to pit President Hitch against Chancellor Young, he was also goading selected Regents to remove them both. Glenn Campbell was a friend of Buchanan’s who shared Buchanan’s low opinion of Hitch and he could be relied on to press the case “against Young, Hitch, and others” with the Regents.59 Buchanan and Campbell were about to spend time together in Munich for the 1970 Mont Pelerin Society meeting, where Buchanan would coincidentally speak on social order in the university (Buchanan 1970).

Angela Davis continued to be emblematic of university chaos for Buchanan after she was arrested in October 1970. While she was in jail and preparing for trial, Buchanan spoke frequently on the topic of universities and the student movement and often invoked the “dangerous” UCLA Communist. In an October 1971 lecture on the economics of public universities in Rock Hill, South Carolina, Buchanan asserted that Davis was “part of a Communist conspiracy to get a Communist on the faculty,” and that the Communist Party “had urged her hiring to foment discord on the faculty” (Perrone 1971, 1). Linda Love, a student in Rock Hill who was active in the Black Student Crusade and local NAACP voter drives (Wilstach 1969) asked Buchanan for evidence of these Communist Party conspiracies. “White people tell us all that,” Love challenged him, “but I want to read it for myself.” Buchanan snapped back at Love that “Black people tell us a lot of one-sided stories too” and apparently did not provide the evidence she requested for his claim about the Communist Party conspiracy.

At Rock Hill, Buchanan also insisted that Davis should not have been hired and that “since she was hired, she should have been fired” (Perrone 1971, 1 and 16). This admission is notable. Although the 1970 shootout presented Buchanan with his “wonderful opportunity” to strike at the UCLA faculty and administration, he admitted in South Carolina that he disapproved of Davis’s initial appointment long before then. A second newspaper account of Buchanan’s Rock Hill speech reports him declaring that professors “whom we can’t trust with the public responsibility should be fired outright” and that if “I were president of a university I would have no compunction about firing them” (Timme 1971).

A week after his Rock Hill speech, Buchanan further elaborated his vision for academic freedom and public financing of higher education in a speech to the professional association for college and university governing boards. The speech was framed as an elaboration of an assertion made in Academia in Anarchy, that taxpayers and the state should maintain ultimate control over what was taught in universities. In the speech, he described his time at UCLA as a trip to “the lunatic asylum” where “serious and quite famous scholars” were “acting and talking as if the taxpayers of California, acting through Governor Reagan and the board of regents, had some sacred obligation to throw increasing amounts of revenues over the university’s ivied walls without so much as a right to inquire what went on behind those walls” (Buchanan 1979, 256).60 Buchanan characterized Davis’s treatment by the Regents as the natural application of the sort of state control he preferred, and marveled that “when the Board of Regents went a step further in the Angela Davis case, when it actually tried to exercise some control over the appointment of an avowed revolutionary to the university faculty, this was taken as a violation of the most sacrosanct of academia’s domains” (Buchanan 1979, 256). He readily conceded that political control of the universities “will necessarily embody an invasion of academic freedom” (Buchanan 1979, 267).

Buchanan’s view that public college and university faculty should be controlled by the taxpayer was common in conservative discourse around Angela Davis and the student movement. Camille Walsh (2018) calls the attitude “taxpayer citizenship,” and points out that historically in the United States it has been highly racialized. Buchanan and Devletoglou’s (1970) book, Academia in Anarchy, was dedicated to “The Taxpayer.” This language and imagery of the tax revolt was also represented in the hate mail that Davis received in jail. One letter signed by “A Hardworking Taxpayer” insisted that “you are not constructive citizens – you tear or burn down rather than build.”61 Another letter signed by “A Taxpayer” proclaimed “more power to pigs!”62 Correspondent “U.S. Taxpayer” accused Davis of wanting to free and arm all criminals.63 Davis and Singleton jointly received a letter from “A Taxpaying Resident of the USA and Proud of It” that suggested that Davis “should got to Russia.”64 Buchanan’s appeal to taxpayer authority over academics thus held broad appeal, even when it violated traditional understandings of academic freedom.

Singleton and Buchanan on Rules and Order in the University

James M. Buchanan is known for the development of constitutional economics, which is, broadly speaking, the economics of the “rules of the game” that economic and political agents play. Not surprisingly, previous analyses of Buchanan’s views on the student movement and UCLA have revolved around questions of constitutional order and the maintenance and enforcement of rules in the university. Despite important differences in their work, both MacLean (2017) and Fleury and Marciano (2018) build their analysis around this constitutional orientation, and both understand Buchanan’s vision for the university as one of constitutional order with consequences for liberal or leftist faculty and student movements that transgress well-defined ‘rules of the game.’ This may be an accurate rendering of Buchanan’s self-conception, even during this period, but it is difficult to sustain as a description of Buchanan’s role in Angela Davis’s ordeal. For all of his theorizing about constitutional order and adherence to the rules of the game, Buchanan encouraged the abrogation of the existing constitutional order in the case of Angela Davis. Warren Samuels recognized this fundamental unpredictability in Buchanan’s thinking on social order when he observed that Buchanan’s “system does not allow us unequivocally to differentiate ‘rebellious activity’ from” the perhaps more legitimate “efforts to eliminate ‘unnecessary’ social control” (Samuels 1976, 936).

In contrast, Davis and her defenders on the faculty insisted that the Regents were bound to abide by the rules of the UC system and the U.S. Constitution. The courts agreed. Buchanan, Reagan, and others rejected this constitutional order and encouraged the Regents to impose increased control over academic freedom on behalf of the state that went beyond their powers under the existing rules of the game. William R. Allen similarly issued his memos asserting new discretionary authority over professors’ academic freedoms in response to clearly constitutionally allowable anti-war protests.

Angela Davis directly challenged the Regents’ violation of the existing rules of the game in a press release, declaring that “in defying the Constitution and in contradicting their own resolution prohibiting the use of political tests as criteria for employment by the University, the Regents have clearly overstepped the limits of their authority.”65 Fred Case and Archie Kleingartner, the chairman and acting chairman of Singleton’s Department of Business Administration, shared Davis’s concerns about threatened university rules, and even called an emergency departmental meeting to discuss “the extent to which customary faculty personnel procedures still have some meaning.”66 The Regents’ disturbance of the rules of the game in 1969 was sufficiently disruptive that when Frederic Meyers resigned as associate dean in protest he confessed to Chancellor Young that he did not know where to submit the resignation because “recent events have made it unclear as to where decisions concerning academic personnel matters are taken,” the administration or the Regents.67

The Angela Davis case therefore demonstrates the difficulty of making simple assertions about Buchanan as a stalwart of constitutional order and rule enforcement in the university. In the case of Angela Davis, at least, he is better thought of as an advocate of punitive order maintained by significant state government discretion over policy and purse strings, even in cases where legal, procedural, and constitutional rules were all clearly on Davis’s side.

Conclusion

This paper tells the history of how two economists, Robert Singleton and James M. Buchanan, became involved in the controversy over Angela Davis at UCLA in the late 1960s and early 1970s. As a young Black doctoral candidate with his plate full of responsibilities, Singleton’s decision to stand up in support of Angela Davis and the nascent UCLA Black studies program (the AASC) is an important episode in the history of economics. Despite radically different views on Angela Davis, Robert Singleton and James M. Buchanan shared an understanding of the institutional forces at work in Los Angeles and across the country in the 1960s and 1970s. They both described how state control over university funding was a source of academic authority that could either be wielded in support of new programs like the AASC or against professors like Davis. Buchanan encouraged the state to wield this authority, while Singleton recognized it as ripe for abuse.

The paper provides the first analysis of archival documents showing that Buchanan followed the Davis case closely after he left California in the summer of 1969. He was furious that the UCLA Philosophy Department hired Davis and that she was reinstated after the Los Angeles Superior Court ruled that firing her for being a Communist was unconstitutional. After the Marin County Courthouse kidnapping incident in August 1970, Buchanan lobbied the Regents to dismiss administrators that had supported Davis. Buchanan’s reaction to Angela Davis shows how abstract appeal to taxpayers’ control of the university can be concretely implemented through personalized elite politics.

Finally, this paper demonstrates the caveats that must be attached to the idea that Buchanan advocated a rules-based constitutional order in the university. In the case of Angela Davis and the student movement, he found the existing rules inadequate for containing the students and faculty that he perceived as a threat. A full understanding of Buchanan’s views on the constitutional order of the university and academic freedom must be informed by how he engaged with Angela Davis.

Notes

  1. There are several oral histories featuring Singleton, which I draw on at certain points in this paper, although none of them have been used by historians of economics. I am not aware of any histories of the Angela Davis affair that discusses Singleton’s role. This may be due in part to the fact that his oral histories feature his role in the Freedom Rides far more prominently than his work on behalf of Angela Davis. [^]
  2. The Afro-American Studies Center has had many names throughout its history, including the Center for the Study of Afro-American History and Culture and most recently the Ralph J. Bunche Center for African American Studies. Because the center was called the Afro-American Studies Center (AASC) during Singleton’s tenure, that name is used here. [^]
  3. One referee for this paper asked how Singleton could be an assistant professor as an ABD student. I have been unable to quantify how common this phenomenon was in the late 1960s, but it appears to have been fairly common. Richard Schier (1970) wrote in “The Problem of the Lumpenproletariat” about how professors who were ABD were especially common in the humanities and the social sciences, and in departments where a PhD was not a terminal degree (such as Singleton’s business school). Angela Davis was hired ABD, and Buchanan is well known for championing the career of Gordon Tullock, who had not pursued a PhD in economics at all. Schier (1970) describes how a tightening academic labor market after the postwar boom was quickly narrowing opportunities for ABD professors, but he makes clear that it was not uncommon at that time. Notably, while Angela Davis was criticized for many things, her ABD status does not appear to have been a major concern for her colleagues, the Regents, Ronald Reagan, or anyone else at the time. [^]
  4. For details, see “Interview with Robert Singleton for the Freedom Riders 40th Anniversary Oral History Project, 2001” University of Mississippi. November 8, 2001 Freedom Riders 40th Anniversary Oral History Project, Archives and Special Collections, University of Mississippi Libraries, https://egrove.olemiss.edu/freeriders/30/, Kemper (2000), and Kwan (2018). [^]
  5. For correspondence between twenty-nine UCLA faculty and either Virgil Roberts (BSU education committee chair), Skip Johnson (BSU president), or history professor Larry Kincaid between May and July 1968 see Series 5, Box 6, Folder 1 of the Robert Singleton Papers, MS 136, Department of Archives and Special Collections, William H. Hannon Library, Loyola Marymount University (hereafter “Singleton Papers”). [^]
  6. Johnson and Roberts to Browne, May 17, 1968. Singleton Papers, Series 5, Box 6, Folder 4. [^]
  7. Syl Whitaker to Charles Z. Wilson, October 18, 1968. Singleton Papers, Series 5, Box 6, Folder 1. [^]
  8. Bernstein (1964) identifies Singleton as working with Bullock on the project, although he was not a coauthor on the final publication, Bullock (1964). [^]
  9. Following Allen’s chairmanship, the UCLA Economics Department did hire Thomas Sowell, albeit only after C.Z. Wilson criticized the Department for initially only offering Sowell a summer teaching position. Allen somewhat confusingly deflected Wilson’s criticism by claiming that “failure to get Sowell here for the entire year is properly imputed to the physical attack on this department last November and to militant black students on this campus” (Allen to Wilson, quoted in Collisson, 2008, 213). [^]
  10. Allen, September 12, 1969, quoted in Fleury and Marciano (2018). [^]
  11. Hirsch to Roberts, June 26, 1968, Singleton Papers, Series 5, Box 6, Folder 4. [^]
  12. Murphy to Singleton, June 19, 1969, Singleton Papers, Series 5, Box 6, Folder 2. [^]
  13. All incidents in the paragraph are described in Allen’s memo to file, “Brief Chronology,” which is undated but presumably written in November 1968. James M. Buchanan Papers, C0246, Special Collections Research Center, Fenwick Library, George Mason University (hereafter “Buchanan Papers”). [^]
  14. Black Students’ Union of UCLA to Charles E. Young, January 15, 1969. Singleton Papers, Series 5, Box 6, Folder 2. [^]
  15. Subsequent document revelations confirmed these suspicions. See Bloom and Martin (2013) for details on the murders. [^]
  16. Davis moved to Los Angeles to participate in an organization that was called the “Black Panther Party,” but was a distinct organization from Huey Newton’s better known Black Panther Party for Self Defense, which Huggins and Carter belonged to. The dispute that she refers to is that in early 1968, members of the Black Panther Party for Self Defense assaulted and threatened her, demanding that the Black Panther Party she affiliated with change its name. They complied and became the local SNCC chapter to expand SNCC’s reach on the West Coast and avoid further confrontation over the Panther brand (Davis, 1974). [^]
  17. Contradicting most accounts, Goetz (2013) argues from a firsthand interaction in 1968 that Buchanan’s decision to leave had already been final after the November bombing attempt, well before the murders. Although Goetz does not appear to have known it, this recollection is confirmed in Buchanan’s letter to Allen, February 12, 1969, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. Buchanan tells Allen that he had already decided to resign and was arranging a move to Virginia Tech in November. [^]
  18. Deliberate FBI provocation of violence between the Panthers and the US Organization and Bureau ties to US are not seriously denied by anyone, although how direct or indirect their instigation of the murders was remained a matter of controversy. See Davis and Weimer (2020) and Henry (2017) for a review. [^]
  19. “Marauders and survival.” May 22, 1969. Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. [^]
  20. “Enforcement of faculty contracts.” May 23, 1969. Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. [^]
  21. “Prosecution of class interruptions.” May 26, 1969. Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. [^]
  22. Allen to Campbell, May 30, 1969. Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. [^]
  23. Filing cards, “Robert Singleton, 1969,” and “Robert Singleton, 1970,” Singleton Papers, Series 5, Box 6, Folder 7. [^]
  24. Buchanan himself wondered out loud to Glenn Campbell whether Academia in Anarchy was a valuable contribution at all. Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 6. [^]
  25. Memorandum from R.L. Shackelford to C.D. Brennan, Book Review: “Academia in Anarchy” by James M. Buchanan and Nicos E. Devletoglou, Internal Security – New Left Matter. FBI HQ file 62-46855. Ernie Lazar FOIA Collection, “FBI Book Reviews” file. [^]
  26. The Ad Hoc Group for the Defense of Academic Freedom. Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 1. [^]
  27. See Angela Davis Defense Campaign Committee Functions, undated, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 4. The other committees were the Angela Davis Defense Fund Committee, On Campus Liaison Committee, Convocation Committee, Information Clearinghouse Committee, and Off Campus Liaison Committee. [^]
  28. All quotes in paragraph from Singleton Statement to Regents, September 16, 1969. Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 1. [^]
  29. All quotes in paragraph from Singleton Statement to Regents, September 16, 1969. Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 1. [^]
  30. Savage was also a member of the Ad Hoc Group for the Defense of Academic Freedom. [^]
  31. All quotes in paragraph from memo titled “CCF Steering Committee Meeting,” notes by Robert Singleton, September 23, 1969, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 1. [^]
  32. “Letter to the Black Community.” September 25, 1969, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 1. One referee for this paper inquired whether Singleton’s view that racism was at the heart of the Angela Davis case was just a “political or communication strategy.” I know of no evidence for this interpretation and I personally doubt it. Singleton risked his life in Mississippi in 1961 fighting racism and was confident in his capacity to identify racism when he came across it. I am not convinced that a man who took the issue seriously enough to risk his life would so lightly use the accusation of racism as a communication strategy. The best interpretation of the evidence is that Singleton and Buchanan were both sincere in their understanding of the problem. I have found nothing in either of their private correspondence that contradicts what they said publicly. It is also worth remembering that “racism” is a broader phenomenon than overt individual racism. Even if not all of the Regents were individually exhibiting overt racism, the actions against Davis could still be a case of structural racism. Angela Davis herself accused the university of structural rather than overt racism in her speech of October 8, 1969 (available at https://comm.ucla.edu/angela-davis-10-8-1969/). [^]
  33. Buchanan, James M. 1969. UCLA and the Militants, Washington Post, October 18, 1969. [^]
  34. Kalish to Singleton, June 18, 1969, Singleton Papers, Series 5, Box 6, Folder 6. Local reporters seemed to have believed that Davis filled a last-minute vacancy, although the correspondence between Singleton and Kalish shows the vacancy was known for months with no plan to offer the course to Davis in the Fall until she requested it. [^]
  35. Superior Court of the State of California for the County of Los Angeles, No. 962388, October 24, 1969. [^]
  36. KNXT Editorial Reply by Robert Singleton, October 26, 1969. Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 4. [^]
  37. Jackson to Singleton, April 6, 1970, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 3. See Sikowitz (2021) for details on Deer Island, Robert Jackson, and the hunger strike. [^]
  38. Nadelson to Singleton, November 30, 1971, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 3. Toni Morrison (1972) wrote a scathing review of Nadelson’s (1972) book, dismissing it as “singularly parochial research.” Morrison in particular describes how Nadelson falsely attributed Davis’s radicalism to white influences alone. [^]
  39. Buchanan to the UC Regents, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 101, Folder 3. Although the draft letter is undated, responses from the regents suggest it was sent August 20, 1970. [^]
  40. See MacLean (2017) for details of the UVA and Virginia Tech protests. [^]
  41. Buchanan to Woodbridge, undated, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 95, Folder 16. [^]
  42. Buchanan to Yeager, May 17, 1970, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 95, Folder 16. [^]
  43. “Herbert Marcuse And Angela Davis At Berkeley,” Pacifica Radio Archives, American Archive of Public Broadcasting (GBH and the Library of Congress), Boston, MA and Washington, DC, accessed March 16, 2022, http://americanarchive.org/catalog/cpb-aacip-28-7d2q52fm0j. [^]
  44. Marcuse, interviewed by Bill Moyers, March 12, 1974, quoted in Marcuse and Kellner (2004, 155). [^]
  45. Robert Singleton appeared before this Commission as a witness at a hearing held in Los Angeles. He was not involved in drafting the report itself. [^]
  46. Allott to Buchanan, September 8, 1970, Gordon Allott Papers, University of Colorado, Boulder, Series VII, Box 12, Folder 130. Buchanan’s letter that Allott is responding to is not included in either the Allott Papers or the Buchanan Papers, but Allott refers to a letter written by Buchanan on August 5, two days before the Marin County Courthouse incident. Buchanan introduced himself in a letter dated May 26, 1970. [^]
  47. Note the distinction here between lower-case c “constitutional,” denoting a codified “rule of the game” in the university and capital c “Constitutional” right to protest, a “rule of the game” enshrined in the Constitution of the United States. These two constitutional orders interact, of course. Angela Davis was reinstated because California rules against hiring Communists were determined by the courts to be a gross violation of first and fourteenth Amendment rights. [^]
  48. See Nisbet to All Economics Faculty, May 16, 1970, and Vakil to All Faculty, May 19, 1970, and Ellickson to All Faculty, undated, all in Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. [^]
  49. Allen to Vakil, May 21, 1970, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. [^]
  50. Allen to Nisbet, May 18, 1970, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. [^]
  51. LaForce to Buchanan, May 19, 1970, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 26, Folder 13. [^]
  52. Branch was a nursing professor at UCLA and founder of the Black Panther Party’s Alprentice Bunchy Carter Free Clinic in Los Angeles in 1969 (Gatrall, 2020). [^]
  53. Branch and Singleton to Nommo, October 1, 1970. Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 4. [^]
  54. Buchanan to the Regents, undated, although replies indicate it was sent August 20, 1970, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 101, Folder 3. [^]
  55. Buchanan to Reagan, undated, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 101, Folder 3. Buchanan probably wrote Reagan on August 20, 1970, the same day that he wrote the other Regents. [^]
  56. Canaday to Buchanan, August 25, 1970, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 101, Folder 3. [^]
  57. Buchanan to Hitch, undated, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 101, Folder 3. Buchanan probably wrote Hitch on August 20, 1970, the same day that he wrote the other Regents. [^]
  58. Buchanan to Campbell, undated, Buchanan Papers, Series 2, Subseries 1, Box 101, Folder 3. Buchanan probably wrote Campbell on August 20, 1970, the same day that he wrote the other Regents. [^]
  59. Hitch’s relationship with UVA and UCLA economists had been tense because of another hiring dispute that occurred in 1968. Hitch vetoed the UCLA Department’s request to hire Warren Nutter, the chairman of the UVA Department and Buchanan’s former colleague. Hitch cited budget constraints and the impropriety of poaching multiple high-profile UVA faculty. UCLA was indeed going through a budget crisis, which William R. Allen conceded when he broke the news to Nutter. Although he gave no evidence for it, Allen suspected Hitch was meting out personal retribution. See Allen to Nutter, Box 79, February 21, 1968, Folder 10 of the William J. Baroody Papers at the Library of Congress. [^]
  60. Although the speech was delivered in 1971 it was ultimately published by Buchanan in 1979. [^]
  61. Papers of Angela Y. Davis, Letters sent to Marin County jail, 1970–1973. [Letters to Angela Davis from the United States – hate mail], 1970–1971. MC 940 55.1, Item 16, Schlesinger Library, Radcliffe Institute, Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass. [^]
  62. Ibid, Item 46. [^]
  63. Ibid, Item 54. [^]
  64. “A Taxpaying Resident of the USA and Proud of It” to President, UCLA, cc Robert Singleton, Angela Davis, and Donald Kalish, October 8, 1969, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 2. [^]
  65. Press Release issued by Miss Angela Y. Davis. September 23, 1969, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8 Folder 1. [^]
  66. Case and Kleingartner to Saxon, September 23, 1969, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8 Folder 1. [^]
  67. Meyers to Young, September 23, 1969, Singleton Papers, Series 6, Box 8, Folder 1. [^]

Acknowledgements

I thank Andrew Farrant, Christopher Fleming, Nathan Tankus, and two anonymous reviewers for helpful comments on a draft of this paper.

Competing Interests

The author has no competing interests to declare.

References

Alkalimat, A. 2021. The History of Black Studies. London: Pluto Press.

Allen, W.R. 1968. “Econ Dept. Chairman Replies to BSU.” Daily Bruin, November 7, 1968.

Anderson, L. R., E. Blanchard, K. Chaston, C. Holt, L. Razzolini, and R. Singleton. 2005. Production and gains from trade. College of William and Mary Department of Economics Working Paper No. 16.

Aptheker, B. 2014. The Morning Breaks. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Bernstein, I. 1964. “University of California at Los Angeles.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 17, no.4: 665.

Betsey, C. L. 2019. “African Americans in Economics at the University of Michigan-Ann Arbor Since the Kerner Commission Report of 1968.” The Review of Black Political Economy 46, no.4: 379–98.

Bloom, J., and W.E. Martin, 2013. Black Against Empire: The History and Politics of the Black Panther Party. Oakland, CA: University of California Press.

Boettke, P. J., J. R. Clark, and J. Kroencke. 2022. “Academic Entrepreneurship in Sometimes Hostile Environments.” The Independent Review 27, no.1: 121–40.

Brennan, G., and J.M. Buchanan. 1985. The Reason of rules: Constitutional political economy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Browne, R. S. 1997. “The African American as Scholar, Economist, and Activist.” In A different vision: African American economic thought, edited by Thomas Boston. New York, NY: Routledge.

Buchanan, J. M. 1970. “The ‘Social’ Efficiency of Education.” Il Politico, 653–662.

Buchanan, J. M. 1979. What Should Economists Do? Indianapolis, IN: Liberty Press.

Buchanan, J. M., and N.E. Devletoglou. 1970. Academia in Anarchy: An Economic Diagnosis. New York: Basic Books.

Bullock, Paul. 1964. “Employment Problems of the Mexican-American.” Industrial Relations 3, no.3: 37–50.

Bullock, Paul and Robert Singleton. 1962. “What to Do With the Drop-out?” The New Republic, 147:17–18.

Collisson, Craig. 2008. “The Fight to Legitimize Blackness: How Black Students Changed the University.” PhD diss., University of Washington.

Conkin, P. K. 1985. Gone with the Ivy: A Biography of Vanderbilt University. Knoxville, TN: University of Tennessee Press.

Darity, W., and A. Kreeger. 2014. “The Desegregation of an Elite Economics Department’s PhD program: Black Americans at MIT.” History of Political Economy 46, no.1: 317–36.

Davies, Lawrence. 1969. U.C.L.A. “Teacher is Ousted as Red.” The New York Times. September 21, 1969.

Davis, A. 1971. Lectures on Liberation. Culver City, CA: Peace Press.

Davis, A. 1974. Angela Davis: An Autobiography. New York, NY: Random House.

Davis, A. 1981. Women, Race & Class. New York, NY: Random House.

Davis, A. 2003. Are Prisons Obsolete?. New York, NY: Seven Stories Press.

Davis, M., and J. Wiener. 2020. Set the Night on Fire: LA in the Sixties. Verso Books.

Devletoglou, N. E. 1966. “Responsibility and Demonstrations: A Case Study.” The Public Opinion Quarterly 30, no.2:285–89.

Espinoza, M. 2017. The Integration of the UCLA School of Law, 1966—1978: Architects of Affirmative Action. Lexington Books.

Fleury, J. B., and A. Marciano. 2018. “The Making of a Constitutionalist: James Buchanan on Education.” History of Political Economy 50, no.3: 511–48.

Gatrall, Corey Ellen. 2020. “Marie Branch and the Power of Nursing” Nursing Clio, https://nursingclio.org/2020/10/29/marie-branch-and-the-power-of-nursing/

Gilmore, Lance. 1969. “Regents Probe Hiring of 2 Leftists at UC.” The San Francisco Examiner, September 19, 1969.

Goetz, Charles. 2013. “How JMB Moved to VPI: Thanks to an Unlikely ‘Party’.” Paper delivered at the James Buchanan Memorial Conference on September 29, 2013, Fairfax, VA.

Greenwood, Leonard. 1968. “Professor Anticipated Trouble, Bought Gun Before Bomb Scare.” The Los Angeles Times, November 13, 1968.

Hall, J. C. (2020). “Academia in Anarchy: 50 Years on.” Public Choice 183, no.3: 405–16.

Hanna, Phil. 1969. “Regents Vote to Bar ‘Red’ from Class.” Los Angeles Herald-Examiner, October 4, 1969.

Henry, C.P. 2017. “Institutionalizing Black Studies at the University of California.” In Black Studies and the Democratization of American Higher Education. Palgrave Macmillan: Cham, Switzerland.

Huggins, Nathan. 1985. Afro-American Studies. New York, NY: Ford Foundation.

Kemper, K. E. 2000. “Reformers in the Marketplace of Ideas: Student Activism and American democracy in Cold War Los Angeles.” PhD diss., Louisiana State University and Agricultural & Mechanical College.

Kumbula, John. 1968. “Black Students Union Denies Any Part in UCLA Bomb Plot.” Los Angeles Times, November 16, 1968.

Kwan, Marion. 2018. “A CORE Freedom Rider: Robert Singleton.” Interview by Marion Kwan, September 30, 2018, https://www.crmvet.org/nars/1809robt.htm.

Levy, D. M., and S.J. Peart. 2020. Towards an Economics of Natural Equals: A Documentary History of the Early Virginia School. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge UK.

MacLean, Nancy. 2017. Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right’s Stealth Plan for America. New York: Viking.

Morrison, Toni. 1972. “Who is Angela Davis?” New York, NY: New York Times, October 29, 1972

Myers Jr, S. L. 2017. “The Production of Black Ph. D.’s in Economics at Harvard University, 1905–1955.” The Review of Black Political Economy 44, no.1–2: 167–201.

Nadelson, R. 1972. Who is Angela Davis?: The Biography of a Revolutionary. New York, NY: PH Wyden.

Nisbet, C. T., & Vakil, F. 1972. “Some estimates of price and expenditure elasticities of demand for marijuana among UCLA students.” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 54(4), 473–475.

Perrone, Betsy. 1971. “Lecturer, Students Argue Davis Firing.” Evening Herald, October 7, 1971.

Reich, Kenneth. 1969. “UCLA Red Lays Ouster Proceedings to Racism.” Los Angeles Times, September 24, 1969.

Reich, Kenneth, and William Trombley. 1969. “Professor Admitted Communist: Explosive Academic Freedom Case Confronts UC Regents.” Los Angeles Times, September 19, 1969.

Rhodes, Barbara. 1970. UCLA High Potential Program 1968–1969. Los Angeles, CA: UCLA.

Roberts, Neil. 2021. “Angela Y. Davis: Abolitionism, Democracy, Freedom.” In African American Political Thought: A Collected History edited by M.L. Rogers and J. Turner. University of Chicago Press.

Rojas, F. 2010. From Black Power to Black Studies: How a Radical Social Movement Became an Academic Discipline. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Samuels, W. J. 1976. “The Myths of Liberty and the Realities of the Corporate State: A Review Article.” Journal of Economic Issues 10, no.4: 923–42.

Schier, R. F. 1970. “The Problem of the Lumpenprofessoriat.” AAUP Bulletin 56, no.4: 361–65.

Seidenbaum, Art. 1969. “Regental Manifesto.” The Los Angeles Times, October 8, 1969.

Sikowitz, J. W. 2021. “The Boston Black United Front and Community-Centered Alternatives to the Carceral State.” PhD diss., University of Massachusetts Boston.

Simms, M. C., and C.A. Conrad. 2019. “Diversity in the Dismal Science: The Stanford Experience.” The Review of Black Political Economy 46, no.4: 362–78.

Singleton, R. 1983. “The Capitalization Effects of Proposition Thirteen.” PhD diss., University of California, Los Angeles.

Singleton, R. 1991. “Using the PLOT Procedure to Avoid Fear of Curves in Economics.” SAS Users Group International 16 Proceedings.

Singleton, R., and P. Bullock. 1963. “Some Problems in Minority-Group Education in the Los Angeles Public Schools.” The Journal of Negro Education 32, no.2: 137–45.

Slavin, A.J. 1968. “Prof Terms Allen Letter to BSU Brutal, Petty.” UCLA Daily Bruin. November 14, 1968.

Sward, Susan. 1969. “Stand for Something, You’re a Hot Target.” UCLA Daily Bruin. October 6, 1969.

Timme, John P. 1971. “Buchanan: Activists Ruining Education.” The State, October 8, 1971.

UCLA Daily Bruin. 1969. “Economics chairman’s ‘intimidating’ tactics hit.”. May 29, 1969.

UCLA Graduate Quarterly. 2010. Untitled. 19(2).

“UCLA Prof Quits Over Violence.” 1969. The San Francisco Examiner. January 26, 1969.

U.S. Department of Labor. 1967. Manpower Research Projects Sponsored by the U.S. Department of Labor, Manpower Administration, Through June 30, 1967. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Labor.

Walsh, Camille. 2018. Racial taxation: Schools, Segregation, and Taxpayer Citizenship, 1869–1973. University of North Carolina Press.

Wilstach, Nancy. 1969. “Black Student Crusade Sets 10-Point Plan.” Evening Herald, July 24, 1969.